
Judgment in the Cloud: The future of risk and regulation with James Lord, Google Cloud
First introduced in 2007 and ramping up in the last few years, several restrictions have been put in place in the UK to limit the promotion and advertising of food and drink products that are high in fat, sugar or salt (“HFSS”), as classified by the Nutrient Profiling Model (“Model”). The Model was originally developed by the Food Standards Agency to classify which foods are more or less healthy and is currently used to categorise HFSS products in the context of all current and forthcoming HFSS restrictions. These restrictions are intended to curtail the consumption of unhealthy food and drink products and thereby tackle obesity, especially childhood obesity, which is often referred to as one of the UK's biggest public health problems. The UK Government has now announced that it intends to make changes to the existing framework. This article summarises the HFSS restrictions currently in existence and considers what appears to be on the horizon.
The current and forthcoming HFSS restrictions can be summarised as follows:
On 3 July 2025, the Labour Government published its 10 Year Health Plan for England (the “Plan”). While focusing primarily on reforming the NHS, the Plan also sets out the Government’s plans to improve the health of the population more broadly. This includes proposals for ending the “obesity epidemic”, noting that obesity rates have doubled in the past three decades with around a fifth of children now leaving primary school with obesity.
The Plan states that the Government will prioritise “smart regulation”, announcing that it will be the first in the world to introduce mandatory health food sales reporting for large companies and promising to do so by the end of the parliamentary term. This is intended to improve transparency in the food industry to help consumers choose, and investors invest in, healthier foods. These figures will then be used to set mandatory targets to increase sales of healthier foods. As the targets will relate to products sold, companies will be able to meet these targets in a number of ways, e.g. by reformulating existing products, introducing new products or changing customer incentive and loyalty schemes. This suggests that the targets will be expressed as a proportion of total sales.
The Government goes on to say that, given its outcome-focused approach to regulation, it expects to repeal the restrictions on aisle placement and multibuy promotions for HFSS products, which were introduced by the previous Conservative Government.
Another important development for companies that are manufacturing products which are close to being categorised as HFSS is the statement that the Model is “plainly out of date” and will be updated, resulting in an estimated reduction of obesity cases by nearly 170,000. This indicates that the Model will be made stricter and that many products currently deemed non-HFSS will come within scope of the restrictions. Even if the restrictions on location and multibuy promotions are scrapped in due course, an update to the Model would remain relevant for the HFSS regulations covering advertising.
The new plans referred to in the Government’s 10 Year Health Plan for England lack in detail, but it is clear that they would represent a shift in the approach taken to the regulation of HFSS products. While the advertising restrictions appear to be unaffected, the Plan suggests that all or most of the restrictions on location and multibuy promotions will be revoked, with new regulations put in place to increase transparency and eventually require companies to proportionally reduce sales of less healthy food and drink products. At the same time, an update to the Model would likely result in more products being classified as HFSS and therefore be subject to advertising restrictions.
While revoking restrictions on pricing and visibility of HFSS products will be welcomed by some, businesses that have already reformulated their products to fall outside of the HFSS regulations may be less pleased with some of these developments, as further reformulations may be required to avoid the restrictions. Meanwhile, the new focus on outcomes will provide businesses with a degree of flexibility and freedom in managing their promotional activities and product portfolios. However, it is likely that, over time, businesses will have no choice but to adapt and shift their focus towards healthier product ranges. The introduction of regulation will at least ensure a level playing field while businesses grapple with this new reality.
Authored by Richard Welfare and Micaela Bostrom.